AITA for telling my future mother-in-law that I don't want to wear her old wedding dress on my wedding day ?

Bride-To-Be Refuses To Wear MIL’s Wedding Dress, Her Fiancé Keeps Nagging Until She Snaps

Weddings are full of love, emotional wedding vows, and those unforgettable moments—like tipsy uncles trying the latest TikTok dance. But let’s be real: for most brides, the biggest spotlight is on the wedding dress. Choosing the perfect bridal gown can be more emotional than actually saying “I do.”

But what if your dream dress comes with a not-so-dreamy backstory?

One bride-to-be on Reddit shared a shocking wedding planning nightmare. Her future mother-in-law insisted she wear her old wedding dress. Sounds sweet? Think again. That vintage wedding gown had a wild history—more action than a nightclub in the ’80s. It wasn’t just “something borrowed”… it came with too many unforgettable memories.

ADVERT

Read for more info Reddit

When the wedding dress has seen more action than your pre-wedding honeymoon, it’s time to run, not walk, from the altar

Bride-to-be pressured by her fiancé and his mom to wear her mother-in-law’s old wedding dress, which she repeatedly used in the bedroom with her husband

ADVERT
ADVERT
Image credits: Alexander Mass (not the actual photo)
ADVERT
ADVERT

The woman considers ending her engagement after discovering her fiancé has a weird obsession with his mom

The original poster (OP), a 29-year-old bride-to-be, was excited to plan her dream wedding with her fiancé Peter. But things took a strange turn when her future mother-in-law made a shocking request—she wanted the OP to wear her old wedding dress on the big day.

Now, this wasn’t just any vintage bridal gown. According to the mother-in-law, it had been part of many “intimate” moments between her and her husband. Yes, the dress had a very X-rated past, and the mother-in-law proudly admitted it had been worn during their private time—more than once. Not exactly what most brides want to hear during wedding planning.

Even though the OP and her fiancé’s mom were the same size (convenient, right?), that’s where the similarities ended. The bride had already told Peter she wasn’t comfortable wearing the dress. I mean, once you hear the words “we made love in it,” the romance kind of disappears.

ADVERT

But the mother-in-law wasn’t ready to give up. She brought it up again at a family gathering, telling everyone how thrilled she was to see the OP walk down the aisle in her “sacred” gown. That’s when the bride snapped and firmly said “No.” No discussions. No compromises.

Cue the dramatic exit—the mother-in-law stormed off in full meltdown mode. But the drama didn’t end there.

Later at home, Peter asked the OP if she liked the sweater she was wearing. When she said yes, he smugly told her it was his mom’s old sweater. Grossed out, the OP took it off immediately and demanded that any clothes from his mom be returned.

Peter’s reaction? He refused to sleep in the same bed, like a sulking child without his favorite toy. The OP’s final move? She sent him a message asking for a serious talk—planning to call off the engagement with a man who seemed just a little too attached to his mother.

Experts might call it emotional enmeshment—a fancy psychology term for a truly uncomfortable situation. Enmeshment means there are no clear emotional or personal boundaries. In these kinds of toxic family dynamics, it becomes hard to tell where one person’s feelings end and another’s begin.

Sometimes, enmeshed parents treat their children like best friends and share too much personal information—like how many times they got intimate with their spouse while wearing their wedding dress. Yep, that really happened. And if that’s not the perfect reason to say “no” to wearing your mother-in-law’s wedding gown, what is?

Let’s not forget—your wedding dress isn’t just fabric and lace. It’s a symbol of your love story. A bridal gown represents dreams, identity, and emotional meaning. In fact, white wedding dresses only became popular after Queen Victoria rocked one in 1840. Before that, brides just wore their best dress, whether it was blue, green—or even mustard yellow!

ADVERT

Today, your bridal gown is your personal fashion moment, your once-in-a-lifetime royal look. It’s the dress everyone cries over, takes a million photos of, and remembers forever. So when someone forces their “well-used” dress on you, it doesn’t feel like a cherished heirloom—it feels haunted by their past.

Wedding planning should be about your future, not about reliving someone else’s awkward romantic memories. And if your fiancé cares more about making his mom happy than respecting your boundaries, you’re not just dealing with mother-in-law drama—you’re waving a dozen red flags.

Netizens side with the woman saying she is not a jerk in this story, advising her to call off the wedding

ADVERT
ADVERT

Related Posts