Person Ends Things With BF Who Demands An Open Relationship, He’s Furious

In some romantic relationships, couples may eventually think about trying an open relationship—where both partners agree to date or be intimate with other people. While this kind of arrangement doesn’t work for everyone, it can be successful if both partners set clear rules, respect each other’s emotional boundaries, and communicate openly.

However, not all couples are on the same page. In this case, one partner wanted to explore the idea of opening the relationship, but the other person strongly disagreed. Instead of continuing the relationship with this big difference, the partner who said “no” decided to end the relationship for good. This left the other partner shocked and heartbroken.

If you’re facing similar issues in your relationship, it’s important to seek relationship counseling, talk to a certified sex therapist, or explore marriage therapy options to understand your feelings and make informed decisions.

Scroll down to read the full story and an exclusive conversation with board-certified sexologist Lilith Foxx and open relationship expert Ally Iseman, founder of Passport 2 Pleasure. They share expert advice on how to navigate the challenges of non-monogamous relationships, and how to know if it’s the right choice for you.

An open relationship can only work if both partners are comfortable with it

Unfortunately, for this couple, it wasn’t the case, so they had to break up

What Is an Open Relationship? Experts Explain the Differences, Misconceptions, and Benefits

Board-certified sexologist Lilith Foxx explained to Bored Panda, “An open relationship is when both partners agree to explore romantic or sexual experiences with other people, but only if there’s clear communication and full consent. On the other hand, a closed relationship means both partners choose to stay sexually and emotionally exclusive to each other.”

Ally Iseman, founder of Passport 2 Pleasure and an expert in open relationship counseling, added, “Today, the term ‘open relationship’ usually refers to a couple—a dyad—who are committed to each other, but also agree to have sex with others. However, many of these agreements still avoid emotional connections outside the main partnership.”

Experts are also clear on one major myth: Wanting an open relationship is not the same as cheating.

“Cheating breaks trust—it’s when someone crosses a line or hides things from their partner,” said Foxx. “In contrast, an open relationship is based on trust, honesty, and open communication from the very beginning. People who choose this path often do so to explore emotional and physical intimacy in a way that works better for their personal needs.”

Foxx also emphasized the importance of being honest: “It’s not about betrayal—it’s about finding what works best for both partners, together.”

Iseman added a powerful insight, saying, “If your partner wants to talk about trying an open relationship, that’s actually a healthy relationship sign. It shows they value what you’ve built and trust you enough to have an honest and possibly uncomfortable conversation. That kind of emotional safety is a great foundation for long-term growth.”

If you’re dealing with this situation in your own life, consider speaking with a licensed relationship therapist, sexologist, or exploring open relationship coaching to make informed, respectful decisions.

Thinking About Opening Your Relationship? Here’s What Experts Want You to Know

Opening up a relationship is a major decision that takes time, effort, and honest communication. Before moving forward, both partners should ask themselves some important relationship questions, says board-certified sexologist Lilith Foxx.

Start with self-reflection and an honest talk with your partner. Ask yourself:

• Can I handle my partner being with someone else without feeling jealous or insecure?
• If I do feel uncomfortable, can I talk openly about those feelings?
• Do I truly want to explore sexual or emotional relationships outside my current one?
• Am I ready for ongoing conversations about boundaries, trust, and emotional health?

“For some people, an open relationship is a perfect fit. For others, it doesn’t work at all,” explains Foxx. “If you’re unsure, that’s okay. Take your time, do your research, and speak to a relationship counselor or sex therapist if needed. Your emotional well-being should always come first.”

Don’t Say “Yes” Just to Please Your Partner

Trying out an open relationship without being sure can lead to emotional stress, resentment, or relationship burnout. “If your partner wants to open the relationship and you’re not ready—or don’t want to—it’s important to say so,” Foxx warns. “You should never feel pressured into something that goes against your values or comfort level.”

Compromise is part of every relationship, but not at the cost of your mental or emotional health. If you’re considering something that feels wrong, set clear personal boundaries and let your partner know how you feel. It’s better to be honest than agree to something that might hurt you later.

What If You Disagree About Having an Open Relationship?

If one partner wants an open relationship and the other doesn’t, it doesn’t always mean the relationship must end. With open-minded communication and mutual respect, it’s possible to explore deeper emotional needs together.

“This kind of conversation can help both people better understand each other,” says Foxx. “Sometimes it leads to changes in the relationship, and sometimes it helps couples find a middle ground that works for both.”

Whether you’re exploring non-monogamy, dealing with relationship conflicts, or just curious about healthy communication in relationships, it’s smart to talk to a licensed couples therapist or a sexologist to help you make the best decision for your love life.

The original poster provided more information in the comments